4.1 KiB
User test
Subject: Victor Tech Skills: High Demography: M, 20-25 Language: En, Da Medium: Android phone (browser unkown) User interface language: En, Da
Following the standard test-protocol
Exploring the interface
1. General impression
(This was done with the old UI based on Leaflet and the UIElement-framework)
- Language picker overlaps
- An "intuitive goal would be to contribute an opening hours of a fast food business"
- "What is a theme? I'll just click it and find out..."
- "Waste seems a sub-functionality?"
Tries to click the green 'pick a theme below for a theme'
"This doesn't seem to do anything, it isn't a link?"
Search for nothing: opens up cyclofix
"Aaahh, I get it - the buttons are themes! So I want to search for restaurants! It filters!"_
Opens up restaurants theme
Exploring the map
1, 2
Pietervdvn switches to develop version of restaurant theme
- "Ooh, I like it better!"
Clicks 'Open map' on the theme introduction view Then uses search to go to Ghent
Data takes a while to load...
Once the restaurants are loaded after ~20m "Oh, wow, there are the restaurants!"
Scrolls/pans to a known friture
"It actually has the opening hours already; then I'll leave a review instead..."
Taps login, uses login with github, signup flow of OSM, checks my changes are in the public domain, goes quite smooth Email validation takes a few minutes to arrive... User pastes confirm link, after confirming the browser opens up to osm.org.
"Oh, this is not your map, but the real OSM"
Attempts login again, "aha, now it knows me", accepts conditions
Leaves a review with 5 stars, it works fine
3: filter for restaurants that are open now
"Oh, you used the word filter, that is indicative of the button "
Found filters right away, toggles open now. "they all have a green clock, so I guess that is it"
4: Change layer
Theme menu "probably this button"
No, not here...
Background button
Switches to sattelite
"allright, can find green located restaurants now"
5: Attribution
The test subject is asked to figure out under which attribution the map data is available.
"My changes are in the public domain, I checked this earlier"
The examinator asks: 'what about the other map data? What license does this have?'
Taps 'menu', 'about MapComplete'
Sees 'privacy policy', 'settings'
"Aha, my pictures are under CC0"
"Maybe when I try to make a change that the license will be indicated?"_
Experiments furthers, opens up shop information
Finds license of the reviews: "is it then my review that turns CC-BY-SA 4.0"? Clicks through to mangrove.reviews for a minute. Which means it is not CC0?
User settings might need a "license information of my changes"? Maybe under 'about mapcomplete'?
Settings on OSM Clicks through to Copyright of OSM (ODbL)
Has a look to privacy policy Oh, surveillance cameras!
Making changes
How do I change the theme?
Unclear how -> To be improved
Goes to surveillance, search should be a bit more fuzzy
Data is slow to load -> readd loading indicator
Taps the map Taps the 'add icon'
Interacts with precise location picker "Really nice"
"Oh, its added!"
"Oh, this is extra information, I'll go out and check"
"It's nice that it tells me it is created. Can I undo creating it?"
No, delete is disabled for cameras
Advanced features
1. Change language
anguage: goes back to language button on index page, sets in Danish
"The translation is a little rough but that is fine"
Opens up drinking water map Goes to home town, mapcomplete freezes for a while
Unclear when data is loading and done loading.
Maybe show an indicator that no data is found?
2: export csv
"I'd go to 'filter' - oh, no its right there" "The danish translation is a bit weird " "Presses CSV - instantly crashes"
Oh, the geojson works
PDF for print Works fine
4: Picture license change
I remember that Menu, settings, CC-BY-40
It is changed!
5:
Get in touch with others!
There is a mastodon
The chatroom for OSMBE was not found